Home


Al franken senate.jpg

Al Franken

After all the court appeals the Republican governor of Minnesota, Tim Pawlenty, signed the certificate of election for Franken and he took office July 6, 2009, for a six-year term. Franken's win gave Democrats a 58–40–2 margin in the Senate, enough to shut off filibusters if the 58, along with two Independents who caucus with the Democrats, hung together.Alan Stuart "Al" Franken (born May 21, 1951), a liberal Democrat and former satirist and comedian known for his attacks against Republicans and conservatives, was the junior U.S. Senator from Minnesota from 2009 until 2018. He was declared the winner of the 2008 general election after purportedly obtaining a slim majority of the votes. The Minnesota Supreme Court rejected the last legal challenges from his opponent, Norm Coleman, who conceded.

Fraudulent election?

The recount that turned Al Franken into a U.S. Senator may have been decided by convicted felons who voted illegally in Minnesota's Twin Cities, it was announced in July, 2010. In a study conducted by Minnesota Majority, a conservative watchdog group, found that at least 341 convicted felons in largely Democratic Minneapolis-St. Paul voted illegally in the 2008 Senate race. The final recount vote in the race, determined six months after Election Day, showed Franken beat Coleman by 312 votes -- fewer votes than the number of felons whose illegal ballots were counted, according to the newly released study, which matched publicly available conviction lists with voting records. The group took the voting lists and matched them with conviction lists and then went to the voting roster lists, where voters sign in before going to the voting booth, and matched them by hand.[1]

Ann Coulter said,

He stole the 2008 election in Minnesota, going from a thousand votes down the day after the election to 300 votes up a few months later, after vast numbers of Franken votes kept being discovered in heavily Democratic districts. As economist John Lott pointed out at the time, the magically appearing votes for Franken were a statistical impossibility[6]

Career

Franken was born in New York City, and spent several years while growing up in St Louis Park, a suburb of Minneapolis. Until he decided to run for the Senate, he lived in California and New York all of his adult life.[2]

Franken was a bit player on Saturday Night Live for nearly two decades, starting in 1979.[3] Unlike many other SNL performers (such as Dan Akroyd, Chevy Chase, Mike Myers, Tina Fey or Steve Martin) he was unable to parlay his time into a successful movie or film career. His one starring film role was in the 1995 movie Stuart Saves His Family, which was a commercial and critical disaster. The film is certified "rotten" on the movie review website Rotten Tomatoes, scoring just 28% positive.[4]

Policies

Franken has been deliberately vague about his position on all major policy issues—except on Iraq, where he reversed himself 180 degrees under intense pressure from the left in Minnesota.

Iraq

In the 2008 campaign, Franken emphasized his strong opposition to President Bush's policies in Iraq. However, he was a relatively late convert to the conviction that the U.S. should immediately pull out of Iraq. Back in 2003 when the country debated the war, Franken supported intervention. He repeatedly visited Iraq to entertain troops, and came to admire them. By 2006 he argued Bush's handling of the war was incompetent, but as late as June 2006 agreed with Bush in opposing a timeline for withdrawal. Pushed by the anti-war left in Minnesota, Franken in late 2006 finally declared his opposition.[5]

Vulgar satire

His career was as a rather vulgar satirist, comedian, and former host for the Air America Radio network. Franken has worked as a comedy writer and performer on the television program Saturday Night Live and was the star and screenwriter of the motion picture Stuart Saves His Family (which was based on his SNL character, self-help show host Stuart Smalley, which has been used by Franken's critics to derisively refer to him after he entered politics). Franken has also written for Playboy magazine, a pornographic publication, although his supporters and the media often skip over that when they talk about him.

Within six months of leaving Air America to assume his Senate duties, the liberal slanted radio network Franken had been with since its founding filed for bankruptcy due to declining listenership, ad revenue, and the unwillingness of investors to absorb further losses.[6]

Style

Franken is known for his anti-conservative hate speak (he has called them "nasty, hateful people" [7]) and his coarse humor. He once quipped to the Harvard Crimson, "I dislike homosexuals. I was glad when that [Harvard] homosexual got killed." [8][9][10] In his book Lying Liars, Franken wrote that a "Methodist minister had had his head up his %#@" in a dispute about the Bible "Do you know what God’s punishment is for liars?" [the minister] asked me ... "God’s punishment for liars is that they believe their own lies." The minister was referring to 2 Thess 2:10-12 which says substantially that. Franken acknowledged his mistake in the paperback version.

At one point his radio show was going to be called "The Liberal Show."[11] but upon debut, it was known as "The O'Franken Factor," a name Franken chose to parody Bill O'Reilly and taunt him into a lawsuit, getting his show free publicity.[12] When the lawsuit failed to materialize, the show was renamed "The Al Franken Show."

2008 election

In the 2008 election campaign, Franken's rudeness, vulgarity, and coarse style led critics to ask about whether he alienated himself from the important undecided swing voters.[13][14] Franken was under fire for an interview he did in Playboy magazine that was considered by many to be unbecoming for a senatorial candidate[15]

The election was very close, with multiple recounts and appeals. On January 5, 2009, the Minnesota election board declared Franken the winner by a razor-thin 225 votes. Coleman filed a lawsuit, which by state law had to be resolved before Franken could be seated.[16] He was seated July 7, 2009, upon which the Wall Street Journal proclaimed that "Mr. Franken now goes to the Senate having effectively stolen an election." [17][18]

Controversial statements

On Franken's website, there is the admonition "Anybody who deliberately propagandizes with lies should be held up to scorn and ridicule".[19] Throughout his books he has held himself to "impossibly high standards" to tell the truth about those he has written about. Author Alan Skorski researched two of Franken's books (Rush Limbaugh is a Big Fat Idiot and Lies and the Lying Liars who Tell Them) and found an extensive pattern of lies, misstatements, factual inaccuracies, among them:

  • Accusing Ann Coulter of "lying with footnotes" by "citing a source and misrepresenting what it says"; throughout his book Skorski states that Franken has done exactly that on numerous occasions (Skorski, pg. xiii).
  • Accusing President George W. Bush of treason.
  • The collision between Bush foreign policy advisor Richard Armitage and news reporter Helen Thomas, which Franken had claimed broke both her hip and jaw (Lying Liars, pg 218), but which Thomas herself said never happened (Skorski, pg 208). After this came to light, Franken later added a footnote in the paperback version of the book saying, "The Helen Thomas thing is a joke."[20]
  • Franken stated he is "often compared to Rush Limbaugh" when on the air, despite the fact that by the time he left his Air America show to run for the U.S. Senate, his radio network was reduced to just over 40 market stations as a result of severely-low ratings and ultimately bankruptcy. Limbaugh, by comparison, plays on more than 600 stations with an average daily listening audience of 22 million (Skorski, pg 303).
  • Franken claimed on his radio show (June 1, 2005) that Rush Limbaugh made up a quotation supposedly said by Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, which claimed Ginsburg said "replacing 'Mother's Day' and 'Father's Day' with a 'Parent's Day' should be considered...". Skorski did a Google check on Ginsburg and discovered a May 20, 2005 column from the National Review Online website entitled "Bench warmers, putting judicial nominees in perspective, part III"; this column cited a September, 1974 article written by Ginsburg which advocated for the creation of a "Parent's Day" to replace both Mother's and Father's Days.
  • Franken claimed John Murphy of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce was lying when he took a pro-CAFTA (Central American Free Trade Agreement) position on PBS's Lehrer Report (July 27, 2005) stating "we've seen unemployment fall to 5.0 percent today, which is lower than it's been in decades."[21] Skorski demonstrated that Franken took the unemployment figures under the Clinton Administration by the month (rather than by the year as the Bureau of Labor Statistics does) and willfully distorted them to make it appear that it was Murphy who was lying (Skorski, pg. 77–78).

Quotes

  • Republicans are shameless d**ks. No, that's not fair. Republican politicians are shameless d**ks.[22]
  • "Nobody likes getting an abortion. Except perhaps, rape victims." [23]
  • Of how big an a-s Brit Hume is, and how shameless, how f---ing shameless these people are, these people are so f---ing shamless." [24]
  • "Ever tempted to run for office yourself?" Franken replied, "Oh, no! First of all, if I took one vote away from a serious candidate, it would be a sin." [25]
  • "If I put myself on the ballot and even 50 people voted for me, it would be a travesty." [26]
  • "It's not preppies, cause I'm a preppie myself. I just don't like homosexuals. If you ask me, they're all homosexuals in the Pudding [Harvard University's Hasty Pudding Theatricals]. Hey, I was glad when that Pudding homosexual got killed in Philadelphia." [27]
  • "The shocking thing about crack is how fast the addiction runs its course. It's not unusual for alcoholics to take 20 or 30 years to hit bottom. Cocaine addicts take maybe a couple of years. Crack, a form of cocaine, usually is a matter of months. The Reagan Administration has been the crack of our nation's debt addiction. And Ronald Reagan, the crack dealer." [28]
  • "In an odd way, I blame Linda Tripp and Ann Coulter for Sept. 11, because if they hadn't dug this stuff up, it may not have happened," Franken on-air comment following separate interviews about 'wagging the dog,' a reference to conservative accusations that Clinton diverted attention from the Monica Lewinsky scandal by launching attacks on terrorists.[29]
  • "I think, for example, "under God" probably shouldn't be in the Pledge of Allegiance, it wasn't put in there since, like the 50's, but it's not that big a deal to me. "In God we trust" probably shouldn't be on the coin. I don't care." [30]

Playboy article

In 2000, Al Franken's comments appeared in a Playboy article titled "Porn-O-Rama!" He was quoted as saying that the Internet is a great tool for learning and that his 12-year-old son was able to do a report on bestiality for a sixth-grade assignment.

Minnesota embarrassment

Tax Issues

During his 2008 campaign, it was discovered that Franken had not paid state taxes in 17 states he earned money over the last four years. Franken blamed it on his accountant saying "This all really comes from one mistake, which is him not understanding that I was supposed to pay state taxes in these other states." Franken says he will pay those states now, plus interest and penalties for a total of $70,000.[31] As of March, 2009, Franken had failed to supply proof that the arrears in taxes had been paid.

United States Senate

Franken was sworn into the Senate on July 7, 2009, and is currently ranked 99th in seniority. To much surprise, a September 14, 2009 Senate AMDT. 2355 prohibiting use of funds to fund the Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now (ACORN), Franken voted with the winning majority to strip ACORN funding.[32] This after having received ACORN support in his Senate election campaign, "I'm thrilled and honored to receive this endorsement," and "more motivated than ever to work with ACORN." [33]

Sexual harassment

In November and December 2017, Franken was accused by several women – with photographic evidence – of groping and sexually harassing them.[34] While liberals and the establishment were significantly more lenient on him than they were on conservative Roy Moore for unproven (and in all likelihood, false) allegations,[35] Franken, after initially resisting calls for his resignation, eventually was forced to announce his resignation "in the coming weeks,"[36] although he cast himself as a "victim" of his accusers.[37] He used his resignation speech to attack Moore and U.S. President Donald Trump.[38] Many of Franken's staffers cried at his resignation speech, and almost every Senator present at his resignation speech – almost all Democrats – embraced him afterward.[39]

Franken officially resigned on January 2, 2018.[40]

Books by Franken

  • I'm Good Enough, I'm Smart Enough, and Doggone It, People Like Me! (Dell Books, 1992) (in character as Stuart Smalley)
  • Rush Limbaugh is a Big Fat Idiot (Delacorte Press, 1996) (a satirical book of personal attacks on Rush Limbaugh as well as other conservatives.)
  • Why Not Me? (Delacorte Press, 1999) (a parody-journal kept through the fictional "Franken for President" campaign)
  • Oh, the Things I know! A Guide to Success, or Failing That, Happiness (Plume Books, 2003)
  • Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them: A Fair and Balanced Look at the Right (Dutton Books, 2003) (targets conservative commentators and the media, particularly Ann Coulter, Bill O'Reilly, Sean Hannity as well as Fox News)
  • The Truth (with jokes) (Dutton Books, 2005) (Franken's view on how George W. Bush beat John Kerry in the 2004 Election with what Al Franken calls the "Fears, Smears, and Queers strategy")

Further reading

References

  1. Jump up↑ Felons Voting Illegally May Have Put Franken Over the Top in Minnesota, Study Finds
  2. Jump up↑ Owen Franken, Biography, statement about where Al Franken resided
  3. Jump up↑ https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0291253/#writer1970
  4. Jump up↑ http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/stuart_saves_his_family/
  5. Jump up↑ Patricia Lopez; Minneapolis Star Tribune, Nov. 30, 2007
  6. Jump up↑ http://www.newmediajournal.us/media/01222010.htm
  7. Jump up↑ Random House.com
  8. Jump up↑ [1]
  9. Jump up↑ [2]
  10. Jump up↑ [3]
  11. Jump up↑ Al Franken, Seriously
  12. Jump up↑ Al Franken's liberal radio network comes to Portland
  13. Jump up↑ http://www.startribune.com/587/story/1083904.html Star Tribune retrieved 6 April 2007
  14. Jump up↑ Franken’s Senate Race Haunted by 1995 Rape Joke on ‘SNL’ Set
  15. Jump up↑ [4] and [5]
  16. Jump up↑ http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090105/ap_on_el_se/minnesota_senate
  17. Jump up↑ Al Franken's Blue Ball; American Spectator, July 2, 2009
  18. Jump up↑ When Dems Don’t Have the Votes, Perkins Coie Finds Them - Big Hollywood, May 7, 2009
  19. Jump up↑ http://lyingliar.com/index.htm
  20. Jump up↑ Franken, Lies and the Lying Liars Who Tell Them, page 227 of the paperback
  21. Jump up↑ https://www.bls.gov/cps/prev_yrs.htm
  22. Jump up↑ The Truth (With Jokes) p. 58
  23. Jump up↑ The Truth (With Jokes) p. 124
  24. Jump up↑ Howard Dean fundraiser, 2003
  25. Jump up↑ Time magazine, 09/01/03
  26. Jump up↑ The Oregonian, 02/22/99
  27. Jump up↑ The Harvard Crimson, 4/16/76
  28. Jump up↑ "Addictions and Mr. Reagan" by Al Franken, The New York Times, 7/19/88
  29. Jump up↑ Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 4/7/04
  30. Jump up↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Rmm5ioINl4
  31. Jump up↑ Accountants: Franken's tax problems should have been caught Minnesota Public Radio, May 2, 2008
  32. Jump up↑ U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 111th Congress - 1st Session
  33. Jump up↑ Katherine Kersten: Worst trouble with ACORN is at the polls, StarTribune, September 26, 2009
  34. Jump up↑ Moran, Sean (December 7, 2017). Sen. Al Franken Will Resign ‘in the Coming Weeks’Breitbart News. Retrieved December 8, 2017.
  35. Jump up↑ Multiple references:
  36. Jump up↑ Moran, Sean (December 7, 2017). Sen. Al Franken Will Resign ‘in the Coming Weeks’Breitbart News. Retrieved December 8, 2017.
  37. Jump up↑ Nolte, John (December 7, 2017). Defiant Al Franken Blames Lying Women for His ResignationBreitbart News. Retrieved December 8, 2017.
  38. Jump up↑ Pollak, Joel B. (December 7, 2017). Al Franken Falls on His Sword So the Party Can Attack Donald TrumpBreitbart News. Retrieved December 8, 2017.
  39. Jump up↑ Weaver, Al (December 7, 2017). 'Ready?': Democratic senators and staffers shed tears during Al Franken's resignation speechBreitbart News. Retrieved December 8, 2017.
  40. Jump up↑ Samuels, Brett (January 2, 2018). Franken makes Senate resignation officialThe Hill. Retrieved January 2, 2018.

External links

  • Al Franken at the Internet Movie Database
  • Al Franken at National Public Radio
  • [7] Al Franken engaging in highly unbecoming behavior

Al Franken Articles

Democrats - the Al Franken party

By Martin Marcus

December 25, 2017

In one of his many attempts at humor, soon-to-be-former Senator Al Franken once declared that the next ten years would be the Al Franken Decade. He was as pompous as can be, strictly for laughs. It was also good training for his future career as a senator. Later, he jokingly took credit for many things, including our current millennium. Of course, he does not deserve credit for society's accomplishments, but he should get some credit for setting the standards of the Democratic Party.

The Democratic Party members refer to themselves as liberals and progressives, but a party that wants high taxes and burdensome regulations, then calls us racist when we protest is not about liberty. A party that wants the socialism that turned Venezuela, potentially the richest country in the world, into one of the poorest is not about progress. What is the Democratic Party about? Immediate gratification.

The Democratic Party caters to people who have a low paying job or none at all. Those with low-paying jobs with no opportunity for advancement got there by not studying in school. They did not understand how lucrative delayed gratification could be. Those with no jobs are more extreme examples of people who just want immediate gratification. The Democrats promise welfare and food stamps for these people at the expense of the rest of us. Meanwhile, they vilify their benefactors, the taxpayers, as if we stole our money. They use phrases such as "I am for regular Americans" (Dr. Howard Dean). Hillary Clinton tweaked this phrase into "everyday Americans" after a focus group study. This means that the Democrats are for some of us and against the rest of us. They are not for the entire country.

Al Franken is a prime example of the Democratic Party. His desire for immediate gratification is observed as he gropes women who are within arm's reach. He does not have the self-control to stop his impulses. Other examples of Democrats who acted like animals are Presidents John Kennedy and Bill Clinton, Senators Ted Kennedy and Chris Dodd, and Congressman John Conyers. A few of the many Democrats in the acting business with impulse control problems include Harvey Weinstein, Roman Polanski, Woody Allen, Bill Cosby, and Alfred Hitchcock.

Why have women not reported these Democrats until recently? They are certainly quick to report Republicans. For example, Republican Congressman Trent Franks was recently forced to resign because he asked women to be surrogate mothers for his and his wife's fertilized egg. In contrast, a woman whom Franken groped said that she voted for him anyway. These women apparently believe that the perpetrator's political positions are more important than his disrespect for the woman's body.

The solution is for the women to report the Democrats as readily as they do the Republicans. This will force the Democrats to be civilized. The women will no longer be potential victims just for choosing to work in Hollywood or Capitol Hill.

As long as they are at it, the women should ask themselves why they support men who act like children. Women should join the Republicans. Statistics show that we are richer, thinner, and smarter. Do not enable losers.

In one of his many attempts at humor, soon-to-be-former Senator Al Franken once declared that the next ten years would be the Al Franken Decade. He was as pompous as can be, strictly for laughs. It was also good training for his future career as a senator. Later, he jokingly took credit for many things, including our current millennium. Of course, he does not deserve credit for society's accomplishments, but he should get some credit for setting the standards of the Democratic Party.

The Democratic Party members refer to themselves as liberals and progressives, but a party that wants high taxes and burdensome regulations, then calls us racist when we protest is not about liberty. A party that wants the socialism that turned Venezuela, potentially the richest country in the world, into one of the poorest is not about progress. What is the Democratic Party about? Immediate gratification.

The Democratic Party caters to people who have a low paying job or none at all. Those with low-paying jobs with no opportunity for advancement got there by not studying in school. They did not understand how lucrative delayed gratification could be. Those with no jobs are more extreme examples of people who just want immediate gratification. The Democrats promise welfare and food stamps for these people at the expense of the rest of us. Meanwhile, they vilify their benefactors, the taxpayers, as if we stole our money. They use phrases such as "I am for regular Americans" (Dr. Howard Dean). Hillary Clinton tweaked this phrase into "everyday Americans" after a focus group study. This means that the Democrats are for some of us and against the rest of us. They are not for the entire country.

Al Franken is a prime example of the Democratic Party. His desire for immediate gratification is observed as he gropes women who are within arm's reach. He does not have the self-control to stop his impulses. Other examples of Democrats who acted like animals are Presidents John Kennedy and Bill Clinton, Senators Ted Kennedy and Chris Dodd, and Congressman John Conyers. A few of the many Democrats in the acting business with impulse control problems include Harvey Weinstein, Roman Polanski, Woody Allen, Bill Cosby, and Alfred Hitchcock.

Why have women not reported these Democrats until recently? They are certainly quick to report Republicans. For example, Republican Congressman Trent Franks was recently forced to resign because he asked women to be surrogate mothers for his and his wife's fertilized egg. In contrast, a woman whom Franken groped said that she voted for him anyway. These women apparently believe that the perpetrator's political positions are more important than his disrespect for the woman's body.

The solution is for the women to report the Democrats as readily as they do the Republicans. This will force the Democrats to be civilized. The women will no longer be potential victims just for choosing to work in Hollywood or Capitol Hill.

As long as they are at it, the women should ask themselves why they support men who act like children. Women should join the Republicans. Statistics show that we are richer, thinner, and smarter. Do not enable losers.

July 31, 2018

Lucky us, Al Franken wants back in

By Monica Showalter

Minnesota's Al Franken, the television "comedian" who got run out of the Senate for sex harassment and general creep-pervert behavior a year ago, sounds as though he wants to run again.

Run, Al, run!

According to the Washington Free Beacon:

Former Sen. Al Franken (D., Minn.) said he hadn't ruled out the possibility of running for public office again during an interview with a CBS Minnesota television station on Monday.

Franken attended the dedication of Bug-O-Nay-Ge-Shig High School on the Leech Lake Indian Reservation.  He sat on the Indian Affairs Committee in the U.S. Senate and helped secure $12 million in funding for new facilities to replace the old one, which was in dismal condition.

"That means a lot to me.  It was very moving for me.  It was very gratifying.  I put my heart in the job," Franken said.  "I miss the whole job.  I loved that job, I loved the job as Senator."

"Will you run for office again?" WCCO-TV reporter Esme Murphy asked.

"Well, see, if I say anything there, you'll put it in the story.  I don't know.  I don't know," Franken said.  "I haven't ruled it out, and I haven't ruled it in."

In other words, he's decided the coast is clear on #MeToo, the group has lost its influence, and too many other leftists have been caught with their hands in the groper's till for voters to care anymore.  Storm over, time to grope again.  No more Twitter calls to resign for disgusting behavior, like this one:

Resign, Al Franken.

Hands up, don't grope.#AlFranken pic.twitter.com/QbREaXgvZQ

— #ThePersistence (@ScottPresler) December 6, 2017

Franken has long been problematic for Democrats over this kind of activity, the kind that gets big-name Hollywood producers unceremoniously thrown out and turns off female (and gentlemanly male) voters.  Yet, Franken being Franken, he has from the beginning thought the rules against being a pig don't apply to him.  He took months and months to resign, falling on his sword ahead of the primaries, in a bid to sacrifice himself for a "blue wave" that probably isn't going to happen.  That cheesed him off, no doubt.  Meanwhile, his minions on Twitter have spread conspiracy theories about how Republican bots, rather than his own behavior, and those wretched photos – not just of the boob-grab above, but plenty of others – did him in.

It was always all other people's fault – their rules, and their publicity.  He was just being a Hollywood guy, see?  It was never he.  It was always the other guy.

And since he's left-wing, it excuses everything.

Conclusion?  Time to run again.  He wants back in, convinced Minnesota's voters will take him, another dinosaur and has-been on the Nancy Pelosi-Chuck Schumer spectrum, addicted to that wonderful Senate power.

Color me skeptical.  Well, go for it, Al.  Just don't imagine that the vote-rigging works every single time.

December 10, 2017

Dems Need Plus-Size Fig Leaf in Ouster of Al Franken

By Geoffrey P. Hunt

So, Al Franken is a lewd boor, an unfunny buffoon, an intellectual midget, and an adolescent crude serial invader of womens’ space. The latter triggered his blindfolded walk-the-plank exit from the USS Senate. 

How convenient for the Democrats to have a do-over, only a third of the way through Franken’s second underwhelming term. 

But the gaggle of Democrat moral peacocks only purged Franken from their caucus because his political value didn’t extend beyond another replaceable vote, a mere commodity. Franken offered zero policy depth, wholly bereft of legislative scholarship, whose exposure on vital Senate committees, such as the Judiciary Committee, was an embarrassment.

Franken’s sacrifice is sleeves off the Dems’ vests. No political risk, an easy flush of a useless white male, clearing the bowl for another swirl of identity politics, a Democrat staple, enabled by fellow progressive Minnesota governor Mark Dayton appointing his #2-- a woman-- to replace Franken.

Just another brazen calculation by the Democrats hoping nobody will notice their naked cynicism.  How gallant, how courageous, how intrepid to now align themselves with sexual mores of the Shakers.

Of course they have tolerated, indeed venerated, womanizers, harassers, sexual predators, rapists, and all-purpose deviants since the days of JFK and his brother Bobby’s peccadilloes, only to be outsized by younger brother “Lion of the Senate” Ted’s willful negligence in forsaking what might have been his pro tempore mistress/girlfriend in tide-swept waters under the Dike Bridge on Chappaquiddick.

Harboring Gerry Studds, and Barney Frank, is a wholly other Democrat party protectorate over sordid abuse, for the sake of celebrating diversity.

This is the legacy of Gerry Studds, the long-serving Massachusetts Democrat who was, for those who followed his lead, every bit the historical figure as the first gay athlete, movie star and politician, but is best known as the congressman censured by his own colleagues in 1983 for a sexual relationship with a 17-year-old male congressional page.

“I think that people in politics and especially people like me who are in politics and lived through that will remember him as being a real hero, because he was willing to be first,” said Richard Socarides, a longtime Democratic operative who served as an adviser to President Bill Clinton for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender issues. “Even though he was forced into it a little bit by circumstances, I think that people think of him as a hero and someone we look up to and someone who was a trailblazer.”

Well at least Jimmy Carter can’t be lumped in with the likes of Ted Kennedy and Bill Clinton. The worst of Carter’s sins is that he“… looked on a lot of women with lust. I've committed adultery in my heart many times.”, according to the sensational Playboy interview in 1976.

Nonetheless even Tony the tent maker can’t stitch a fig leaf big enough to cover two generations of Democrat sleaze.

May 3, 2008

Al Franken the tax deadbeat

By Clarice Feldman and Rosslyn Smith

Yesterday, AT noted  Al Franken's problems as a tax deadbeat in several states. Franken blames his accountant, though he refuses to allow  his accountant to speak to the press. Minnesota Democrats Exposed reports today that the largets newspaper in the state, the Star-Tribune, has sent a reporter to New York to interview Franken's accountant. When performers or athletes or others earn money in a state, they must file a state income tax report on the earnings, and this is what FRanken reportedly failed to do in a number of states.

As a CPA I find the Franken tax situation an amusing lesson.  I suspect the accountant probably advised Franken of the obligations and Franken told him not to prepare returns for the non resident states.  I had that happen more than once with people who owned pass through entities that operated in several states. Often the client made this decision after weighing the costs of being caught by the non resident state against the additional fees involved in preparing several state tax returns.  I never had it happen with an athlete or an entertainer, however. That's because people in those industries tend to be aware they wear a target that screams TAX ME every time they enter another state or a foreign country. Large paychecks and high profiles make them all but irresistible to local revenue authorities.    

Income from the performance of services is considered earned where the services are performed.  Technically speaking, whenever I spent a day at a client in a neighboring state, I had an obligation to file an income tax return in that state for that day's salary unless an agreement existed between that state and my state of domicile that I need only pay tax where I live. States don't go after the tax on a few days pay from an employee based in another state because it isn't cost effective. The line starts to get hazy when that day every now and then stretches into an assignment of several weeks duration. 

A huge exception exists for athletes and entertainers. For one thing few people except the desk clerks at the motel notice when a team of IT consultants from California spends several weeks in Asheville, NC.  People in three states knew when George Clooney and Renee Zellweger were in nearby Anderson, SC filming Leatherheads.   One day is all it takes in some cases. 

Whenever the Seahawks play the Patriots in New England, everyone on the team has Massachusetts income tax withheld because of the 24 hours they spent in that state. Same thing when a Disney affiliate films a movie with scenes shot in multiple locations. If the director insists on spending five days in Central Park while the rest of the movie gets filmed in California, both New York state and New York City expect taxes to be withheld on everyone involved in establishing the story takes place in Manhattan. Ditto if a TV show goes on the road and films at a special location for a week. The local government offices that help arrange locations and permits also check that tax laws are being fully complied with. Thus networks, studios and sports teams are used to sometimes issuing Forms W-2 to a half a dozen different states or more on behalf of a single employee.  

Given these industry practices, it's hard for me to believe that TV veteran Franken did not know his state income tax filing obligations. 

Since both New York and Minnesota are high income tax states, it may be correct that Franken actually didn't pay less state tax in total because the state of domicile will credit income taxes paid to non resident states.  It all depends on what the income was for and which states are involved. For example, with athletes is their contractual pay to be divided by the number of games played during a regular season, or by the total days spent in practice, preseason and any postseason personal appearance obligations as well?  Each state may have its own rules, so some income can get taxed twice.

Franken's talk about the records being unavailable probably has to do with the statue of limitation (SOL), which is usually three years from the initial date the return was due or when it was filed if that date was later. Thus the SOL on 2003 returns ran out sometime in 2007, depending upon if he filed an extension that year. Every CPA firm I worked with kept the last 4 year's returns on premises. Prior years' returns were often kept in long term storage off site and could take time to locate and retrieve. 

Where Franken may now be out of luck is that there is usually also a three year SOL for filing a refund claim ,while there is no SOL for assessing income tax when no return has ever been filed. Thus if the non resident states go after Franken for years before 2004, he will be double taxed because his state of domicile will no longer allow any claim for refund on the credit for taxes paid to the nonresident state(s). 

When a client passes on filing nonresident state returns their CPA usually warns them of this risk as well as that of the assessment of interest and penalties than can amount to more than the income tax itself. When a state decides to go back eight or ten years and recreate returns that were never filed, the decision to save a couple hundred bucks in accounting fees up front quickly turns into a bad bargain.

Since Franken's has become a high profile case, some of the nonresident states involved may well look back further than 2003. It is a given among Directors of Revenue that nothing encourages compliance more than a news story about a famous non filer having to pay back taxes, interest and penalties. .